Privacy Ref Blog

Privacy Impact Assessments: Organization-specific or Generic PIAs

I recently had a conversation with a colleague about privacy impact assessments, PIAs, and the tools available to administer them. We quickly became philosophical, trying to weigh whether a generic tool would work or if something that is organization specific is necessary.

What do PIAs offer?

Generally speaking, PIAs offer a way to gather information about changes in the collection, processing, sharing, and destruction of personal information kept by an organization. The information about these changes allow privacy pros to decide if the proposed approaches are compliant with an organization’s privacy policies as well applicable statutes and regulations. Based on this evaluation, the proposed application or business process changes will be approved or modified as appropriate. PIAs should be used for new applications and business processes as well as changes to existing operations.

A PIA can take many forms. I have seen document-based questionnaires through elaborate IT applications. The implementation selected should be based on the acceptability of the PIA process to your organization, the maturity of your organization and process, the resources available to the organization, and, of course, your organizational culture.

No matter the implementation method selected, a PIA should give enough information to the privacy pro doing the evaluation to understand the benefits and risks associated with the new uses of the personal information.

Anything else?

With increasing frequency, I am seeing risk determination and ownership placed in the business and operational areas of an organization that access and use personal information. This is opposed to a traditional model where the ownership of risk lies in a centralized privacy function. While the accountability for privacy remains with a centralized organization in these cases, the Privacy Office for example, the responsibility for implementation of privacy protections and practices is becoming distributed.

A PIA, therefore, should not only provide information to a privacy pro in a centralized function, but should also provide an indication of compliance and risk to the submitting person or group prior to submission of the PIA to a centralized privacy function for evaluation. Providing this indication will serve as an educational device for the groups submitting PIAs as well as reduce the PIAs submitted to the centralized privacy function that end up requiring some form of remediation.

Organization-specific or generic PIAs?

As the International Association of Privacy Professionals points out, a privacy program needs to be specific to an organization. Even two companies in the same industry with the same products will have unique programs. The basis for this statement is that the organizations may have different risk tolerances, different infrastructures, different business processes, and (of course) different people with unique experiences in their backgrounds.

In addition to the information that is gathered and how it is evaluated, how the PIA is administered is vital to its acceptance. Defining a mechanism that is perceived as rigid, time-consuming, or bureaucratic will be rejected in most organizations. As a result, finding or developing a tool that fits your organizational culture is a consideration when deciding how to implement with a PIA process.

Given the uniqueness of privacy requirements, programs, and risk tolerances, I suggest that a PIA must be organization specific. While a generic tool or process may be used as a foundation to establish a PIA approach, an organization must be prepared to invest time and resources to adapt the tool or process to their particular needs.

PIA implementation advice

If you are just implementing a PIA process, I suggest you take take small steps. Through a simple survey process and the provision of feedback, show how a PIA can provide value to your organization. Through refinements, adjust the process to provide additional value to the teams your privacy office is supporting. Through this approach you will get buy-in for the extra effort that the PIAs will need and avoid being labeled as “simply more paperwork”.

If you decide you are ready to select or build a tool to increase the automation of your PIAs, have those people that submit PIAs be part of the tool selection/definition team. Make them part of the decision-making process; after all, they will need to use the tool and probably have a perspective on the process that is different from the one held by the privacy office.

Privacy Ref provides consulting and assessment services to build and improve organizational privacy programs. For more information call Privacy Ref at (888) 470-1528 or email us at info@privacyref.com

Posted on December 7, 2015 by Bob Siegel
Tags: , ,

« »

No Responses

Comments are closed.


« »

Subscribe to our mailing list

Please fill out the form below.

Required

Want to find out more?

Simply go to the contact page, fill out the form, and someone from Privacy Ref will be in touch with you. You can also send an email to info@privacyref.com or call (888) 470-1528.

News

April 16, 2018

IAPP Training Classes
Privacy Ref is proud to announce that we are an official training partner of the IAPP. You now have the opportunity to learn from one of our knowledgeable privacy professionals using the most respected training content in the industry. The robust interactive training offered, aids in the understanding of critical privacy concepts. The contents of the courses are integral to obtaining your privacy certifications and to educate your new team. Learn more here.

Latest Blog Posts

July 9, 2018

Don’t Forget Basic Communication
Most of us have been wrapped up in GDPR preparations for several months. While there are many organizations "not quite there yet", many others have made great strides towards compliance. As we continue to do assessments for clients, both GDPR and General Privacy,  I have been surprised at the frequency of the gap between a privacy official describing their organization's data subjects, information collected, and business processes  with the reality of what is happening. Continue reading this post...

California – The Next GDPR?
Starting January 1, 2020, if you are a for-profit company doing business in California, you may have new data privacy compliance obligations. Specifically, California just enacted the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (the country’s strictest data privacy law to date), placing new privacy mandates on certain businesses with respect to the personal information of consumers (defined as natural persons who are California residents). Many aspects of the new law smack of EU-GDPR influences, such as a new and improved (in other words, broader) definition of personal information and the inclusion of guaranteed consumer rights with respect to such personal information. If your business is already in compliance with the EU’s GDPR, the California law will be nothing new to you. For other businesses, however, you have 18 months to get with the program. Continue reading this post...

Other Recent Posts

PRIVACY REF